Grading the Arizona Cardinals' most recent free agent moves
The Arizona Cardinals have made several moves in free agency this week. We graded those first moves from early in the week. Since adding linebackers Josh Sweat and Akeem Davis-Gaither and re-signing linebacker Baron Browning, guard Evan Brown and tackle Kelvin Beachum, they have done more.
They added quarterback Jacoby Brissett, linebacker Mykal Walker and defensive tackle Dalvin Tomlinson. They are bringing back receiver Zay Jones and defensive tackle L.J. Collier. They tendered receiver Greg Dortch.
What grades do they deserve for those moves?
Arizona Cardinals free agency grades, Part 2
QB Jacoby Brissett: B
Brissett gives the Cardinals a proven backup quarterback who can win games in a starters role. Granted, he is only 19-34 in 53 career starts, he has the NFL's lowest interception percentage in league history among qualified quarterbacks. He is experienced. He is reliable. He is a much better option than Clayton Tune, although much more expensive at $12.5 million over two seasons. This is the most the Cardinals have ever paid for a backup quarterback.
DT Dalvin Tomlinson: A+
The Cardinals swung and missed in their attempt to land Milton Williams, who got $26 million per year to join the Patriots. Instead, they get a more proven player in Tomlinson, cut by the Cleveland Browns only for cap reasons, for $29 million over two years. This is a home run of a deal. He is disruptive, consistent and a proven commodity both against the run and the pass.
LB Mykal Walker: B
Walker is fine. He is a special teams player with starting experience. The Cardinals need experienced depth and special teams play. And at under $2 million, it's fine. Nonetheless, it isn't a signing to get excited about. He is just a guy they need at a position that people won't notice.
WR Zay Jones: C
Jones only had eight catches last season and got a contract worth double than the one he had last season, making a reported $4.5 million this coming season. That said, he is a better player than he performed. His five-game suspension to start the season really derailed his season. Should they go get another receiver? Probably, but a trio of Jone with Michael Wilson and Marvin Harrison Jr. is at least a group you can play a game with.
WR Greg Dortch (tender offer): C
Dortch can still test the market but can return at his highest salary ever at $3.3 million. However, that is not guaranteed. As a receiver, he isn't reliable. He is a playmaker with the ball in his hands, so they have to manufacture touches. At minimum, the Cardinals secure their punt returner at a reasonable price.
DL L.J. Collier: B
Collier, playing in every game for the first time since 2020, was solid. He started 15 games and had a career-high 3.5 sacks. He is a solid NFL starter, but having him as a rotational player makes things even better. While he might not produce more than he did last season in a different role, if he has the same numbers while being the fourth or fifth-best D-lineman on the team, that means the team is significantly better.
Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire's Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on Spotify, YouTube or Apple podcasts.
This article originally appeared on Cards Wire: NFL free agency grades: Looking at Arizona Cardinals' recent moves
-
Arizona Cardinals given a 'B' in early NFL free agency grades
The Cardinals have made some moves. This publication gives them good but not great marks in free agency grades.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Cardinals free agency grades, reactions, recaps
Jess Root and Seth Cox react to the Cardinals' moves in free agency in the latest edition of the podcast.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
2 great NFL free agency moves by Arizona Cardinals they hope they don't need
Two of the Arizona Cardinals' moves in free agency were for players that ideally won't have to play much in 2025.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Grading the Dolphins moves in the first week of free agency
What was the best move made by the Dolphins in the first week of free agency?Yahoo Sports - 1d -
The Arizona Cardinals' 3 best moves in NFL free agency
The Arizona Cardinals wrapped up the first week of free agency making a bunch of moves. These three were their best ones.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Grading each Cowboys move in 2025 free agency: Dallas goes bargain bin shopping despite plenty of cap space
The Cowboys have $37.6 million in effective cap space, the 10th-most in the NFL, after an active free agency runCBS Sports - 2d -
2025 Tennessee Titans free agency: Experts, insiders offer mixed grades
The Tennessee Titans are a week into the 2025 free agency period and have made some interesting moves that have been met with some mixed reviews.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Arizona Cardinals' projected starting lineup after NFL free agency
With some new additions and some returning free agents, we take a look at what the Cardinals' starting lineup would look right now.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
NFL free agency grades: Bears, Broncos, Vikings impress in first wave, Texans confound
Plenty of NFL teams have made significant upgrades in the early stages of free agency. Here's a look at the best- and worst-graded teams.Yahoo Sports - 4d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
As Brandon Graham retired, Jalen Hurts showed why Eagles don't have a leadership void
This player showed why Eagles have a true leader as Brandon Graham joined Jason Kelce and Fletcher Cox in retirementYahoo Sports - 18m -
Greeks summon legend of King Otto before Scotland tie
Almost 21 years on from Greece's greatest triumph, Scotland's opponents have their sights set on Nations League A.Yahoo Sports - 20m -
EA Sports paying players $1500 to be in College Football 26
EA Sports is increasing how much college football players will be paid in NIL deals for appearing in this year's video game.Yahoo Sports - 20m -
Evans seeks Glasgow glory after 2014 Games inspiration
Neah Evans says it would be "incredible" to go for gold at next year's Glasgow Commonwealth Games as she is "part of the legacy" of the 2014 event in the city.Yahoo Sports - 22m -
Formula 1 in 2025: How to watch the Chinese Grand Prix on TV and what to know
— Other countries are listed here. What is the Chinese Grand Prix schedule? — March 23: The Chinese Grand Prix. Where is the Chinese Grand Prix taking place? The 5.45-kilometer (3.39-mile) ...Yahoo Sports - 23m
More in Sports
-
As Brandon Graham retired, Jalen Hurts showed why Eagles don't have a leadership void
This player showed why Eagles have a true leader as Brandon Graham joined Jason Kelce and Fletcher Cox in retirementYahoo Sports - 18m -
Greeks summon legend of King Otto before Scotland tie
Almost 21 years on from Greece's greatest triumph, Scotland's opponents have their sights set on Nations League A.Yahoo Sports - 20m -
EA Sports paying players $1500 to be in College Football 26
EA Sports is increasing how much college football players will be paid in NIL deals for appearing in this year's video game.Yahoo Sports - 20m -
Evans seeks Glasgow glory after 2014 Games inspiration
Neah Evans says it would be "incredible" to go for gold at next year's Glasgow Commonwealth Games as she is "part of the legacy" of the 2014 event in the city.Yahoo Sports - 22m -
Formula 1 in 2025: How to watch the Chinese Grand Prix on TV and what to know
— Other countries are listed here. What is the Chinese Grand Prix schedule? — March 23: The Chinese Grand Prix. Where is the Chinese Grand Prix taking place? The 5.45-kilometer (3.39-mile) ...Yahoo Sports - 23m