We can’t be a republic only when it’s convenient
![We can’t be a republic only when it’s convenient](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/05/supreme_court_04292024_AP_AP24120713767875.jpg?w=900)
Are we a constitutional republic unless it’s inconvenient? This is a question the Supreme Court faces. Let us hope its answer is no.
This term, the court has seen multiple important cases challenging regulators’ use of powers, processes and funding structures that allegedly exceed constitutional limitations. One such case deals with whether regulators, in this instance the former superintendent of New York state’s financial regulator, can threaten firms for doing business with advocacy groups they disagree with.
This case cuts to the heart of the checks, balances and limitations on government action meant to protect American liberty.
To be sure, the superintendent’s lawyers argue that the conduct is, in fact, constitutional. If this is the case, the court should say so, as it did just this week by upholding the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s controversial funding structure. However, defenders of both challenged regulators have also pushed heavily on arguments that if the court finds against the government, it will hamper government action and may even result in chaos.
The superintendent allegedly used her power over banks and insurance companies to target groups whose message she disagreed with. This included public warnings that doing business with these groups could harm a firm’s reputation, something firms have an obligation to monitor and the regulator claims discretion to judge.
Supporters argue that if this were found to violate the First Amendment, it would risk making the financial system less safe and chill the ability of prosecutors and regulators to act.
These arguments boil down to the idea that fully enforcing the Constitution would make the government’s life too hard. That if regulators’ and prosecutors’ actions were subject to First Amendment scrutiny — and if bank and insurance regulators have their broad assertions of discretion questioned — they wouldn’t be able to function like they currently do, risking financial instability.
The court must not be persuaded by these arguments.
First, it’s highly unlikely these dire predictions will come to pass. As Professor Julie Andersen Hill’s work shows, it’s doubtful that regulators’ ability to pressure banks and insurance companies based on the reputation of their customers makes those firms meaningfully safer. And if regulators and prosecutors are unwilling to act while subject to First Amendment limitations, the action probably wasn’t justified or wasn’t that important — or we need new prosecutors.
Second, the Constitution wasn’t designed to make everything easy for the government. It places strictures on how the government operates. It is true that without these restrictions, the government might be better at achieving certain desirable ends. After all, forcing everyone to wear a GPS tracker would make solving and preventing crimes much easier. But that’s not the deal we made as Americans.
The government, including legislators, must figure out how to address problems within the limits of the Constitution. The court deferring to convenience would negate this obligation and risk us increasingly exchanging liberty for not even security, but mere bureaucratic ease.
Finally, the court should reinforce its responsibility to enforce the Constitution as it is. If the government exceeds that framework, even for a noble purpose, the answer is not to legitimize bending the rules; it’s to return to an approach that works within the Constitution or allow the people to settle the question through an amendment.
This is the core of self-government. The more the court deprives the people of that obligation, the more our ability to meaningfully self-govern will atrophy.
This would pose a far greater threat to the interests and liberty of the American people than any mere regulatory matter. The Constitution is far from perfect, but it’s vastly superior to a rule of government convenience.
Brian Knight is the director of Innovation and Governance and a senior research fellow with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
This is how we do it: ‘We were both anxious when we met, but our sex life is a lot of fun now’
Harry wasn’t sure he’d love again after his wife died, and Meredith’s ex was ‘Victorian’ in bed, so finding each other has been a joy. • How do you do it? Share the story of your sex life, anonymously. My body just reacted. I suddenly felt, I’d ...The Guardian - World -
When our young son died, we decided to build him a boat
Wild Cat Island had always held a special place in the imagination of our son, so after his funeral we chose to try and send him on one last journey. Famously, Windermere is the setting of the children’s adventure story Swallows and Amazons by ...The Guardian - World -
I’m 64 and retired to watch my grandkids. My husband, 65, and I have $1.7 million. When should we claim Social Security?
“Should we wait longer to collect Social Security and live off of our 401(k) plans for two years?”MarketWatch - Business -
At the G7, Biden Can’t Escape the Shadow of the Gaza War
The president was miffed when, expecting to talk about a security pact with Ukraine, he was asked for updates on the Gaza cease-fire plan.The New York Times - World - Joe Biden -
The Only App That Always Wins the Battle for Your Attention
Duolingo taps into the power of streaks and hooks you with perfectly timed nudges. Can its success translate to other companies?The Wall Street Journal - World -
It’s Tough to Get Things Done in New York. Here’s Why.
Congestion pricing was the latest ambitious proposal that couldn’t navigate New York’s rocky political terrain. It’s a tall order to achieve substantial change in the city.The New York Times - Top stories - New York -
Prof Arturo Casadevall: ‘It is hubris to think a fungal pandemic can’t happen to us’
Could a fungus trigger a Last of Us-style apocalypse? The author of What If Fungi Win? says despite dangers, the organisms are of great use to science. Arturo Casadevall is a professor of molecular microbiology and immunology at the Johns Hopkins ...The Guardian - World -
The Boys Complete Comic Book Series Is Only $18 For A Limited Time
There's a new--and very good!--season of The Boys on TV right now, and in case you're keen to read through the source material, you can get a diabolical deal on the original comic books right now. Over on Humble, the entire run of The Boys is ...GameSpot - Tech -
When rural communities welcome immigrants, everyone wins
The picture of rural America as a dying wasteland home to a dwindling number of angry white people may appeal to folks who have never been here. But it’s wrong.The Hill - Politics -
It’s not a question of if but when Israel goes to war with Hezbollah
Is it better for Israel to act sooner or later?The Hill - Politics - Israel
More from The Hill
-
Harris announces $1.5B aid package for Ukraine at peace summit
Vice President Kamala Harris announced a $1.5 billion aid package for Ukraine in its war against Russia at the Summit for Peace Saturday in Switzerland. "This war remains an utter failure for [Russian President Vladimir] Putin,” Harris, said ...The Hill - Politics - Ukraine -
Biden campaign raises $28 million in lead up to Los Angeles fundraiser
Flying straight from the G7 summit in Italy, President Biden arrived in Los Angeles this morning for a fundraising event with former Presidents Obama and Clinton, comedian Jimmy Kimmel, and actors George Clooney and Julia Roberts. The event has ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Cuba-Russian relations come full circle — why US policy must reflect this reality
These strengthening Cuba-Russia military and economic ties, coupled with growing economic and social despair in Cuba, should serve as an important wake up call to the U.S. and its Western allies.The Hill - Politics -
Seasonal affective disorder strikes some in the summer. Climate change may make it worse.
Story at a glance When spring comes and daylight hours grow longer, Greg Flick, a high school science teacher in Syracuse, N.Y., starts to feel depressed. “I can appreciate the beauty of it and the temperatures aren’t bad, but I know what’s ...The Hill - Politics - Climate -
Charlamagne tha God signals he will vote for Biden over Trump in November
Charlamagne tha God got into an intense exchange with late night host Bill Maher Friday, as the two discussed who the radio personality would back in November. Maher asked the “Breakfast Club” radio host on where his mind is in an interview, as a ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden