House Republicans' farm bill proposal 'robs Peter to pay Paul,' Agriculture secretary says
The House Agriculture committee is trying to fund its farm bill proposals with “counterfeit money,” Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack told reporters Wednesday morning.
Vilsack spoke after a range of groups from across the political spectrum criticized House Republicans’ proposed farm bill, which seeks to direct tens of billions to subsidies for farmers of peanuts, rice and cotton.
House Agriculture Committee Chair Glenn Thompson (R-Pa.) told reporters these increases — which he said were necessary to make up for rising costs of inputs like fuel and fertilizer — would be paid for by freezing increases to food aid, and by cuts to the Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC), which allows administrations to make emergency loans.
But Vilsack noted that the Congressional Budget Office has found these cuts — which are deeply unpopular among Democrats — fall well short of what is needed to pay for Thompson’s proposed increases.
Thompson’s camp disputes these findings, and The Hill has reached out for further clarification.
The House, Vilsack said, “doesn’t have the resources, if they follow the rules, to be able to do everything that they're doing.”
“You can’t rob Peter to pay Paul,” he added.
The House bill, unveiled by Thompson last week, would increase the “reference prices” for cotton, peanuts and rice. Analysis from the Environmental Working Group suggests those changes would lead to farmers of those commodities getting paid out over the next five years no matter what.
That plus proposed increases to crop insurance could cost between $50 billion and $100 billion — though the Congressional Budget Office doesn’t yet have firm numbers, and may not have them before the current farm bill expires.
That price tag poses a serious challenge for the House because Congress has said this farm bill must be “budget neutral,” meaning additions in one area must be balanced by cuts in another.
The trouble, Vilsack argued, was that the “creative math” in the House Agriculture Committee's bill doesn’t work. He compared the plan to a parent who “at Christmas time you go out and buy all the gifts on credit. And then the bill come due in January and then you'd have to really tighten the belt and you have to make serious sacrifices, which nobody likes.”
In the upper chamber, Senate Agriculture Committee Chair Debbie Stabenow (D-Minn.) has run up against the same dilemma, but taken a different — though similarly fraught — approach: Her committee’s bill is up to $20 billion over the budget, and she plans to ask Congress for more money.
“She basically went to the leadership and said I need additional money … to be able to raise reference prices to be able to satisfy some of the concerns that have been expressed by folks out in the countryside,” Vilsack said. “Why aren't we seeing that from the majority?”
The situation, the secretary stressed, is urgent. The failure of last year’s farm bill amid the chaos in the House meant that the bill — usually passed every five years — was thrown into limbo.
Last September, as the five-year bill expired, Congress passed a one-year supplemental that kept all programs running at their previous levels — but left the broader trajectory of American agriculture in doubt.
As Democrats’ and Republicans’ mutually exclusive red lines on the issue loom over the process of negotiating a new farm bill, and the possibility of a second failure looms, long-term planning is becoming ever more difficult for farmers, bankers and conservationists.
All those camps, Vilsack said, “want the same thing: they want to know what the rules of the road are going to be for the next five years.
“So the failure to get the farm bill done, makes it more difficult for farmers, for rural communities for businesses to be able to plan and to be able to implement in order to create economic opportunities.”
In comments after Vilsack's call, Thompson fired back, calling it an "eleventh-hour push" and defending both the cutbacks to the CCC and the savings they would yield. Thompson accused the secretary of using "every penny of the borrowing authority made available to him to circumvent Congress if left unchecked," and said his committee was "reasserting Congress’ authority over the Commodity Credit Corporation, which will bring reckless administrative spending under control and provides funding for key bipartisan priorities in the farm bill."
“Funding the farm bill is always a puzzle, and finding the right pieces to produce a strong farm bill has been tricky but also a worthwhile," he said. “The sudden rancor on using the CCC as a pay-for is nothing more than the latest partisan attempt to divide our committee and slow down progress on passing a farm bill.”
Date: |
Filter
-
House Republicans pass key military bill with new limits on abortion and DEI initiatives
House Republicans passed a key military policy bill with new restrictions on abortion and diversity, equity and inclusion policies.NBC News - Top stories - Abortion -
House GOP approves mammoth annual defense bill
Presented by Sikorsky, A Lockheed Martin Company — The bill is accompanied by various culture war amendments. {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story House GOP approves mammoth annual defense bill The House ...The Hill - Politics -
Inside the room during Trump's visit with House Republicans
Politico - Politics - Donald Trump -
House GOP approves mammoth annual defense bill with culture war amendments
The House approved its version of the annual defense policy bill that includes a number of controversial culture-war amendments Friday, setting the stage for a showdown with the Democratic-controlled Senate over legislation that typically enjoys ...The Hill - Politics -
House G.O.P. Pushes Through Defense Bill Nixing Abortion Access Policy
The annual defense policy legislation emerged from a House committee with bipartisan backing, but Republicans loaded it with right-wing mandates targeting abortion, transgender care and diversity initiatives.The New York Times - Top stories - Abortion -
Defense policy bill, Garland contempt push in spotlight at House Rules
Politico - Politics -
Senate Republicans block bill on women’s right to IVF as Democrats make push on reproductive care
Senate Republicans have blocked legislation that would make it a right nationwide for women to access in vitro fertilization and other fertility treatmentsABC News - Health - Republican Party -
Longtime House Republican faces pricey primary full of fighting words — and football
Rep. Tom Cole is the latest House Republican on defense this year, facing a primary challenger from the right in Oklahoma.NBC News - Politics -
DOJ declines to prosecute Garland after House Republicans pass contempt resolution
Garland had refused to turn over audio of Biden's special counsel interview.ABC News - Top stories - Republican Party -
Trump offers an olive branch to the House Republicans who voted to impeach him
Politico - Politics - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
Eyeing Trump presidency, conservatives want to delay funding fight
Bullish of former President Trump’s chances of winning back the White House in November, some conservatives are pitching a funding stopgap that would extend into next year rather than expire during a lame duck session when President Biden would ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Iran and Sweden to swap prisoners, including convicted war criminal
Iran agreed Saturday to release two Swedish nationals held in Tehran for over two years in exchange for a convicted Iranian war criminal tied to the 1988 mass killing of protestors critical of the Islamic Republic in the capital city. While ...The Hill - Politics - Iran -
Raskin hits Republicans for bowing to 'sugar daddy' Trump after Capitol visit
Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) criticized his Republican colleagues in Congress Saturday after they met with former President Trump in closed-door meetings earlier this week, calling the positivity around the visit "a scandal and a disgrace." The ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Sunday shows preview: Trump sells GOP unity with Capitol visit
Former President Trump made an appearance on Capitol Hill this week, attempting to rally Republican lawmakers during his first time meeting with Congress since the Jan. 6, 2021 riots. Several of his most loyal supporters will make appearances on ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
America is full of the living dead — and Mississippi is ground zero.
lawmakers in Mississippi and across this nation must finally put people over politics and deliver much-needed policies like Medicaid expansion and increased access to health care to meet the urgency that this crisis demands.The Hill - Politics