House crypto bill sows the seeds of the next financial crisis
A buzzy new financial player, once thought invincible, nearly collapses due to poor management and reckless bets gone wrong. Congress holds hearings. Regulators offer measures to limit speculation and increase disclosures and oversight. But the industry calls this approach burdensome and harmful to investors. An industry champion makes a case for a lighter touch regulatory approach and succeeds.
This scenario, plucked from the 1990s derivatives industry, has eerie parallels to today, as the House considers cryptocurrency legislation. The Financial Innovation and Technology for the 21st Century Act, the industry claims, will foster innovation while protecting consumers. But we should fear a repeat of the past — a bill that fosters weak regulation for crypto and undermines investor safeguards.
In the 1990s, the firm was Long-Term Capital Management, a hedge fund. In 1998, the firm nearly collapsed due to a series of bad trades that cost it $4.6 billion. To avoid contagion, the New York Fed and private firms stepped in with a cash infusion. Congress then held hearings, a presidential working group studied the issue, and Treasury came up with regulatory ideas for the esoteric financial products that brought down LTCM, known as swaps and over-the-counter derivatives.
But then there was a changing of the guard.
Lawrence Summers, notably, replaced Robert Rubin as Treasury secretary. Suddenly, the word was that derivatives and swaps should be less regulated. Summers argued that “these products have transformed the world of finance” and that “a cloud of legal uncertainty” over the industry could “discourage innovation and growth...driving transactions offshore.”
Soon after, Congress approved his recommendations, and then-President Clinton signed a deregulation bill, the Commodities Futures Modernization Act. As one expert later put it, “Although many factors contributed to the financial meltdown of 2008, it is now almost universally recognized that principal among them was the collapse of the unregulated swaps market.”
The parallels between this old crisis and crypto today are striking. Sam Bankman-Fried courted acclaim from the media, celebrities and Congress right up until his firm FTX collapsed in scandal. Congress then held hearings expressing outrage and calling for reform. Quickly, the crypto industry recalibrated, claimed FTX was an outlier, and insisted that the real problem was onerous regulation and legal uncertainty stemming from the Securities and Exchange Commission, led by Gary Gensler, who was stifling crypto innovation and driving economic opportunities offshore.
Echoing the 1990s, Summers even made a cameo as a paid adviser to crypto firms, touting crypto’s economic potential, despite his past questionable calls.
This crypto bill is the brainchild of the industry’s lobby and its friends in Congress, and it shows. The bill uses a murky definition of crypto’s decentralized technology to legitimize risky industry practices. It gives primary regulatory authority over crypto markets, via a rubber-stamp self-certification process, to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, an underfunded and understaffed agency that lacks a retail investor protection mandate.
Until the bill’s rules are established, the bill exempts crypto firms from ongoing regulatory enforcement actions. It does all this at the expense of SEC oversight and its more robust investor protections. What little SEC oversight that remains is watered down, such that even online crowdfunding schemes for raising capital would receive more oversight than many crypto firms.
The bill’s worst feature rewrites longstanding securities law for crypto’s benefit by exempting a large set of crypto products from the definition of "security" in the SEC’s authorizing law, even though many crypto products clearly are securities and should be regulated as such. This loophole would erode key protections for crypto buyers and create a roadmap for traditional Wall Street firms to evade existing rules, which could further fuel risky speculation and harm a wider array of investors, even if they never touch crypto.
Will Congress remember the lessons of the 1990s? Some view this vote as mostly about seeking favor from (or avoiding the ire of) crypto super PACs fueled by a few Silicon Valley billionaires who stand to gain, and who are promising to spend tens or even hundreds of millions of dollars this election cycle. Others genuinely want to protect crypto investors but aren’t sure how. Many know little about crypto or financial regulation in general and are being told that this bill is a step forward. But it’s a recipe for trouble.
Policymakers need to take this seriously and stand up for the public interest. There may be a crypto regulatory proposal that strikes the right balance, but this isn’t it. Instead, this bill could sow the seeds of a new financial crisis. If members of Congress don’t want their vote to be the first chapter in the history of that crisis, they should vote against this bill.
Mark Hays is senior policy analyst at Americans for Financial Reform and Demand Progress.
Date: | |
Tag: | Crypto |
Filter
-
House GOP approves mammoth annual defense bill
Presented by Sikorsky, A Lockheed Martin Company — The bill is accompanied by various culture war amendments. {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story House GOP approves mammoth annual defense bill The House ...The Hill - Politics -
House GOP approves mammoth annual defense bill with culture war amendments
The House approved its version of the annual defense policy bill that includes a number of controversial culture-war amendments Friday, setting the stage for a showdown with the Democratic-controlled Senate over legislation that typically enjoys ...The Hill - Politics -
House G.O.P. Pushes Through Defense Bill Nixing Abortion Access Policy
The annual defense policy legislation emerged from a House committee with bipartisan backing, but Republicans loaded it with right-wing mandates targeting abortion, transgender care and diversity initiatives.The New York Times - Top stories - Abortion -
Defense policy bill, Garland contempt push in spotlight at House Rules
Politico - Politics -
House Republicans pass key military bill with new limits on abortion and DEI initiatives
House Republicans passed a key military policy bill with new restrictions on abortion and diversity, equity and inclusion policies.NBC News - Top stories - Abortion -
House GOP leaders strike controversial abortion pill ‘rider’ in new funding bill
Politico - Politics - Abortion -
Donald Trump flips on crypto: From 'scam' to building a 'crypto army'
In a sharp reversal, former President Donald Trump has embraced the cryptocurrencies he once reviled, looking to outflank rivals Joe Biden and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.NBC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Taiwan must prepare for cyber, financial attacks by China
As China conducts military exercises around Taiwan, it is important not to forget about less visible methods of attack. In addition to military threats, Taiwan must prepare for the risk of electronic and financial attacks. Indeed, the ...The Hill - Politics - China -
This crypto ETF could give you income and hedge inflation
Ether ETF with a ‘staking’ feature would offer something bitcoin ETF doesn’t — potential for capital appreciation and dividends.MarketWatch - Business - Crypto -
Meloni’s G7 sustainable food plan faces political, financial gridlock
Yahoo News - World
More from The Hill
-
Democratic lawmaker slams Project 2025 as 'un-American'
Rep. Madeleine Dean (D-Pa.) slammed Project 2025, a grand sweeping plan by Republicans to advance right-wing priorities and expand the powers of the presidency, as "un-American" in a new interview Saturday. Dean, speaking on MSNBC Reports, did not ...The Hill - Politics -
Greene alleges Fauci committed 'crimes against humanity' with COVID response
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.), speaking at a Turning Point Action conference on Saturday, vowed to have former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Anthony Fauci sent to prison over his handling of the ...The Hill - Politics - Covid -
Scaramucci suggests CEOs backing former president have 'Trump-nesia'
Former Trump White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci suggested that some CEOs have “Trump-nesia” two days after former President Trump attended the quarterly meeting of Business Roundtable, with over 80 CEOs present including ...The Hill - Politics -
Watch live: Trump gives keynote at 'The People's Convention' in Detroit
Former President Trump is set to headline Turning Point USA's "The People's Convention" Saturday in Detroit. Trump, the presumptive GOP nominee for the White House, is also expected to use the trip to key battleground state Michigan as a way to ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Crockett calls Thomas 'corrupt' after Supreme Court decision to upend bump stocks ban
Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) slammed Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas as “corrupt” during an interview with MSNBC on the court’s recent decision to overturn a Trump-era bump stock ban. Thomas has come under increasing scrutiny for gifts he ...The Hill - Politics