Higher education is failing — and our democracy is suffering
![Higher education is failing — and our democracy is suffering](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/04/AP24114000249441_382fc3.jpg?w=900)
This commencement season, on some college campuses’ anti-war protestors are finding resolution with administrators, while on other campuses, things remain contentious. The student protest movement is not a monolith. It's complex and may look different in different places — and depending on one's viewpoint.
Is it free speech to be protected or punishable bad behavior to be deterred? Is it standing up against violating Palestinians' human rights or antisemitism? Does it reflect specific objections to policies that can be fixed, or polarization and cancel culture that can't be appeased?
It may be useful to think about these questions through the lens of higher education’s function of fostering the next generation of engaged citizens, advocates and leaders. The students who occupied tent camps this year will occupy boardrooms and courtrooms in the years ahead. What core values and core competencies will they need to learn and practice in college?
We’re in a high-stakes, teachable moment, but we could use more clarity about exactly what should be taught to whom. Passionate dissent about the Israel-Hamas conflict is an accelerant for angst over a perfect storm of big, existential threats students feel, including climate change, democracy teetering on the edge, economic inequality and disruption, artificial intelligence, and much else.
Higher education plays a critical role in tackling such existential problems, or rather, in preparing students to tackle them. In the U.S., that role has evolved over time in successive waves.
The first two waves produced small, elite “Greek academies,” founded in the 18th century, followed by state-chartered colleges and universities that began to enlarge the curriculum beyond Greek and Latin. Subsequently, there emerged the singularly American innovation of land-grant colleges, built on federally owned land and funded by an act of Congress in 1862. They were to be “accessible to all, but especially to the sons of toil,” meaning of farmers and laborers. Instead of just transmitting high culture, they deliberately fostered economic development for all, and were known as “democracy’s colleges.”
This democracy-building mission was reaffirmed by President Truman’s 1947 Commission on Higher Education, which wrote that the “first and most essential charge upon higher education is that at all levels and in all its fields of specialization, it shall be the carrier of democratic values, ideals, and process.”
But if that’s the mission, higher education may be failing.
Only 57 percent of young people (ages 18-35) recently polled in 30 countries believed that democracy is preferable to any other form of government, compared with 71 percent of those over 56. Young people were twice as likely to support military rule. More than a third felt that a “strong leader” who did not hold elections or consult the legislature was “a good way to run a country.”
To turn this around, educators must grapple anew with the question of how to teach democracy, so that students master both the theory and the hands-on practice of it.
U.S. colleges and universities increasingly offer channels for students to engage in their communities. This is much more than an exercise in so-called “town-gown” public relations; practicing civic engagement is a crucial part of higher education. Civic engagement is a very powerful way to apply what students have learned in the classroom, to learn to work together across differences to solve community problems. It is an exercise in how to listen to multiple perspectives, persuade, bridge divides and compromise — how to “do democracy.”
Democracy requires that people who may misunderstand and disagree with each other, even passionately, learn to respect and understand each other, and find a way forward. Teaching and training this ability has traditionally been one of the most important parts of a liberal arts education, but it’s a civic virtue in short supply today.
The fact that college students are motivated to protest the war in Palestine is in itself a positive marker of civic engagement. Cases where student protestors negotiated with the administration, struck agreements, and the tents and trauma were put away — at least for the time being — are a sign of educational success. Cases where pro-Palestinian protestors and pro-Israel demonstrators clashed with one another or with police, with one or both sides retrenched, are a sign educators have more work to do.
American college students are often passionate about engaging issues. That’s a resource for democracy that educators should build on, to teach productive, problem-solving, civic engagement to every single student, universally. We need a Civic Engagement Corps. The federal government should help by reaffirming, as it did in 1947, that democracy is higher education’s essential mission, supporting initiatives and sharing best practices.
As former U.S. congressman, federal judge and White House counsel Abner Mikva said, “Democracy is a verb.” Educators aren’t equipped or entitled to tell students what nouns to choose, what the specific object or content of their civic engagement should be, which position on an issue a right-thinking educated person must adopt as a signal of virtue. But educators are equipped and obligated to teach the thought processes and actions of democracy itself. If nothing else, today’s challenging times and rising stakes are making this clearer.
This is a teachable moment, and it’s time to teach.
Margee Ensign, Ph.D., is president of the American University in Bulgaria. Previously she served as president of the United States International University-Africa; as president of Dickinson College; and as president of American University of Nigeria.
Date: |
Filter
-
Baltimore educator to be honored at Tony Awards
CJay Philip, an actor, dancer and educator from Baltimore, is the winner of the 2024 Excellence in Theatre Education Award, and will be honored Sunday at the 77th annual Tony Awards.CBS News - Entertainment -
Comex Gold, Silver Settle Higher
Gold settled up 1.4%, with silver also rising 1.4% on the day. Both metals posted weekly gains.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Come to Our Destination Wedding!
It is impossible to put a price on friendship, but in this case it’s about $6,403.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Ukraine's Global Diplomatic Flurry Fails to Outflank Russia
President Volodymyr Zelensky’s peace summit this weekend in Switzerland threatens to expose cracks in Ukraine’s effort to keep the world rallied behind its vision for ending the war.The Wall Street Journal - World - Ukraine -
Surprise, Tesla Investors Vote for a Higher Share Price
Right or wrong, Elon Musk and his investors are co-believers in a glorious if imprecise future.The Wall Street Journal - World - Tesla -
We’re in our 70s and don’t trust our family to handle our estate. What can we do?
There are options for people who don’t have family — or don’t want their family — to handle their affairsMarketWatch - Business -
'Manhunt' star: Lincoln's assassination is still a call to protect democracy
One of the thrills of "Manhunt" is watching the wheels turn inside the actor's character's head, and how those wheels then determine what appears on his face: consternation, resignation, outrage.Los Angeles Times - Entertainment -
Rising violence against politicians is an attack on democracy itself | Simon Tisdall
Seemingly random assaults in Britain and other parts of Europe are coming from left and right. The response of Mette Frederiksen, Denmark’s centre-left prime minister, to being physically assaulted in a Copenhagen street was dignified and very ...The Guardian - World -
Scotland’s main men fail to lead in a ragged capitulation to Germany | Ewan Murray
Steve Clarke has a job on his hands to rouse a team who failed to keep the ball and offered no threat in Munich. You wait decades for such an occasion and this happens. Scotland had cause to wonder whether the fevered level of anticipation that ...The Guardian - World -
Singer Cody Simpson fails to make Australian Olympic swimming team
International pop star Cody Simpson put his music career on hold to return to the pool.CBS News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Greene alleges Fauci committed 'crimes against humanity' with COVID response
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.), speaking at a Turning Point Action conference on Saturday, vowed to have former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Anthony Fauci sent to prison over his handling of the ...The Hill - Politics - Covid -
Scaramucci suggests CEOs backing former president have 'Trump-nesia'
Former Trump White House Communications Director Anthony Scaramucci suggested that some CEOs have “Trump-nesia” two days after former President Trump attended the quarterly meeting of Business Roundtable, with over 80 CEOs present including ...The Hill - Politics -
Watch live: Trump gives keynote at 'The People's Convention' in Detroit
Former President Trump is set to headline Turning Point USA's "The People's Convention" Saturday in Detroit. Trump, the presumptive GOP nominee for the White House, is also expected to use the trip to key battleground state Michigan as a way to ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Crockett calls Thomas 'corrupt' after Supreme Court decision to upend bump stocks ban
Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) slammed Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas as “corrupt” during an interview with MSNBC on the court’s recent decision to overturn a Trump-era bump stock ban. Thomas has come under increasing scrutiny for gifts he ...The Hill - Politics -
Eyeing Trump presidency, conservatives want to delay funding fight
Bullish of former President Trump’s chances of winning back the White House in November, some conservatives are pitching a funding stopgap that would extend into next year rather than expire during a lame duck session when President Biden would ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump